In just a matter of seconds, most people can memorize the contents from a television advertisement or the Internet. Just after watching an advertisement for a few seconds, a child can probably recite half of the whole script. Media has a way of getting to our minds within a few seconds of a glance. With its never-ending reach to billions of people, it is really necessary for social media to be beneficial for the population. Nicholas Carr’s “Is Google Making Us Stupid” and Johnson’s “Watching TV Makes You Smarter” focus on how media have changed the way in which we learn and grow as individuals in today’s world. They express how television and Google can have an impact on an individual to such an extent which was previously unimaginable. Although both of these writers have a different perspective about the usefulness of social media, but they both agree that media has a large impact on the lives of people.
While Johnson argues that television is having a positive effect on the society and is making us smarter, Carr contends that Internet, especially Google, makes us stupid and is detrimental in our growth as intellectual beings. While both authors are taking completely different paths, they still have a lot of similarities in their thought processes. If one considers each argument separately instead of together, one can infer that both authors are considering arguments that defy what the current society and tradition teaches us. Also, both of these authors try to examine the changes in our society due to the incoming of media like Google and television.
How both authors try to put their points across is really different and each one could be benefited by the style of the other author. Carr uses ethos as well as logos to prove his point and Johnson compares examples of television shows from the past and the present to argue for a change in the criteria used to determine if a television show is good or not. Carr uses a few studies of Internet behavior and also...
Please join StudyMode to read the full document